Monday, January 09, 2006

Not a mainstream kinda guy

Nathaniel at The Film Experience had made mention of this in a recent blog entry. He talked of Engin's great filmsite (collecting all those critic's Top 10 Lists and compiling a master list - exhaustive and I am damn glad I don't have to do it, because if he hadn't, my OCD and list-making obsession would probably have forced me to attempt it, and in the meantime go comepletly insane). Nathaniel made mention of how often his own Top 10 has "matched up" with the overall Top 10. Engin has been doing the list since 2001 and here is my take on the whole thing (aka: how I matched up year for year):

2004: just 2 (Before Sunset & Kill Bill 2)
2003: 2 again (Lost in Translation & Kill Bill 1)
2002: 3 (Far From Heaven, Y Tu Mama & Spirited Away)
2001: 3 (Mulholland Dr., Memento & In the Mood for Love)

I suppose I'm not very "mainstream" eh?

Here are my match-ups on the annual Village Voice Poll (a much more selective group):

2005: five
2004: four
2003: three
2002: six
2001: five
2000: five
1999: five

Anyway, there you have it.

In other news, coming sometime tonight will be my Best of 2005 column on my site. Stay tuned.

1 Comments:

At 8:29 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hello, its me again, the anonymous Top Ten Project watcher from the Weitz post...

how my super-snobby Top Tens compares with Enigen's "consensus":

2005 - 2
2004 - 2
2003 - 2
2002 - 2
2001 - 6 (sometimes the mainstream is right!)

compared to the Village Voice:

2005 - 5
2004 - 7 (incredibly!)
2003 - 4
2002 - 3
2001 - 5
2000 - 4

and compared to one of my favorite on-line mavens...Senior Knox:

2005 - 4 (haven't seen your Top 4, and reject Crash) but the rest make it with the Clooney in my Top 20
2004 - 1 (Weerastehakul -sp?)...plus 1 more in my Top 20
2003 - 6 [Top Match of all critics that year] - I hate KillThrill, didn't love Triplets, Real Girls is in my Top 20, and am watching Saraband tonight!
2002 - 1 (VanSant)...plus 1 more in my Top 20
2001 - 3 (Lynch, Tsai, "The Innuit")...plus 1 more in my Top 20
2000 - 3 (Tarr, Trier, Yang)...plus 3 in my Top 20
1999 - 4 (Dardenne, Kitano, Kiarostami, "Kauffman")
1998 - 1 (Twyker)...plus 4 in my Top 20
1997 - 3 (Kiarostami, Tsai, Wong...haven't seen the Sokurov yet)...plus 2 in my Top 20
1996 - 2 (von Trier, Assays)...plus 1 more in my Top 20

Hope this was of some tiny interest to you; just a fun way to spend a little time flipping through my Cinema Scrapbook. Keep up the good work! And update those Top Tens!!! Cheers.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home